The 16 Best Options for Cake Delivery in NYC
NYC is a famous city in the United States. With the Statue of Liberty, Empire State Building, Central Park and Theatre District, it’s a must-visit for tourists, especially during special occasions. Those with a sweet tooth will also be happy to know that the city is home to numerous bakeries. What’s more, most of them deliver right to your doorstep! If you’re looking for a bakeshop in New York City, here are your best options.
Note: Most of the companies are still permitted to deliver cakes to their clientele through online orders. Some of them also offer curbside pickups to maintain social distancing. Where there’s a limited store operation or updates regarding these shops during the pandemic crisis, we’ve noted them below.
1. City Cakes
| BEST FOR | Designer cakes |
| SELECTION SIZE | Small, medium and large |
| PRICE RANGE | Calculated depending on design |
| DELIVERY FEE | Calculated upon checkout |
| WEBSITE | https://citycakes.com/ |
| CONTACT | 616-688-2286 |
| PAYMENT | Visa, MasterCard |
City Cakes is a premier bake shop that specializes in designer cakes. They are featured in prominent magazines, shows and publications such as The Knot, Brides, Food Network, Rachael, Halloween Wars and TLC. Their cakes are not only delicious – they’re works of art too.
2. NYC Birthday Cakes
| BEST FOR | Custom birthday cakes |
| SELECTION SIZE | Small, medium and large |
| PRICE RANGE | Calculated depending on design and size/Personal quote needed |
| DELIVERY FEE | Calculated upon checkout |
| WEBSITE | http://nycbirthdaycakes.com |
| CONTACT | 800-933-7835 |
| PAYMENT | Visa, MasterCard |
As the name suggests, NYC Birthday Cakes are your go-to shop for birthdays. However, don’t expect your generic sheet cake from the shop. They personalize every piece to make sure each order is unique.
3. Buttercup Bake Shop
| BEST FOR | Classic American cakes |
| SELECTION SIZE | Small, medium and large |
| PRICE RANGE | Starts at $36 |
| DELIVERY FEE | $20 |
| WEBSITE | http://www.buttercupbakeshop.com/ |
| CONTACT | 212-757-6900 |
| PAYMENT | Visa, MasterCard |
Buttercup Bake Shop was established by Jennifer Appel. Although she was originally in the field of psychology, she’s always had a passion for baking. Today, her bake shop is a favorite among celebrities like Hillary Clinton, Martha Stewart and Al Roker. She’s also been featured on several TV shows, such as The Today Show, Fox, CNN and MTV, among others.
4. Billy’s Bakery NYC
| BEST FOR | Homemade cakes |
| SELECTION SIZE | Small, medium and large |
| PRICE RANGE | Starts at $40 |
| DELIVERY FEE | $35 |
| WEBSITE | https://billysbakerynyc.com/ |
| CONTACT | 212-647-9406/212-625-3323/212-371-1133 |
| PAYMENT | Visa, MasterCard, American Express, Discover |
Billy’s Bakery was established in 2003, by two friends who have a passion for cakes. Marc and Wayne were friends for 25 years before they decided to open their small bake shop. Today, it’s a favorite among New Yorkers because of their delicious pastries.
Note: Given the current COVID-19 situation, their Billy’s Bakery NYC branches will close down, except for the flagship store at Chelsea. Even then, their work hours are shorter than usual, and that they receive a torrential number of calls, so you have to be patient.
5. Krumville Bake Shop
| BEST FOR | 100% gluten-free bakery |
| SELECTION SIZE | Small to large |
| PRICE RANGE | Starts at $3.95 |
| DELIVERY FEE | Free local delivery on orders above $50 |
| WEBSITE | https://www.krumvillebakeshop.com/ |
| CONTACT | 917-406-7447 | orders@krumvillebakeshop.com |
| PAYMENT | Visa, MasterCard, American Express, Discover, Apple Pay |
Krumville Bake Shop is an artisanal, online gluten-free bakery. All of their desserts are made with the freshest ingredients available. Count on them to create both sweet and savory baked goods for any occasion!
Note: Their online shop is still open where you can have your sweet, delectable cakes delivered starting from next week, 18th May, Monday.
6. Caffé Palermo
| BEST FOR | Cannoli |
| SELECTION SIZE | Large |
| PRICE RANGE | Contact for details |
| DELIVERY FEE | Contact for details |
| WEBSITE | https://www.caffepalermo.com/ |
| CONTACT | (212) 431-4205 |
| PAYMENT | Contact for details |
For more than 46 years now, Caffé Palermo has provided people in NYC and all over the world with the best Italian pastries and best cannoli that money can buy. Each of their recipes is made with only the best ingredients for a consistent delicious flavor that you just cannot get anywhere else.
Online ordering is available to ship their pastries anywhere in the world. They also offer local delivery, including lunch and dinner, with their concierge service.
Reach out to them to get a taste of their mini and flavored cannolis. They even have one sin both sizes!
Note: Caffé Palermo is opening this May 18th to offer curbside pickup as well as free delivery within the local area for purchases of $25 and up.
7. Eileen’s Special Cheesecake
| BEST FOR | Cheesecakes |
| SELECTION SIZE | Small to Large |
| PRICE RANGE | Starts at $85.00 |
| DELIVERY FEE | Shipping is included in the prices |
| WEBSITE | https://www.eileenscheesecake.com/ |
| CONTACT | 212-966-5585 | info@eileenscheesecake.comContact form |
| PAYMENT | Contact for payment options |
Eileen’s Cheesecakes are the quintessential NYC dessert. Every Eileen’s Cheesecake is made with love and captures the heart and soul of this family’s passion for cheesecake in every bite!
Note: In response to the COVID-19 dilemma, they offer contactless curbside orders. You can log in to their site and order away!
8. YehCakes
| BEST FOR | Custom cupcakes |
| SELECTION SIZE | Small to Large |
| PRICE RANGE | Request for quotes |
| DELIVERY FEE | Request for quotes |
| WEBSITE | https://www.yehcakes.com/ |
| CONTACT | hello@yehcakes.com | 646.883.9347 |
| PAYMENT | Contact for payment options |
YehCakes offer baked-to-order custom cupcakes and fondant toppers. All of their personalized designs are handmade for all your events, celebrations, and gifts.
9. Baked Cravings
| BEST FOR | Nut-free, Peanut-free |
| SELECTION SIZE | 8” – 12” pans, 1 – 3 layers |
| PRICE RANGE | Starts at $50 |
| DELIVERY FEE | Calculated upon checkout |
| WEBSITE | https://www.bakedcravings.com/ |
| CONTACT | 646-590-3324 |
| PAYMENT | Visa, MasterCard, American Express, Discover |
Baked Cravings is a bakeshop located in Lexington Avenue. It was founded by Craig Watson specifically to cater to people with dietary restrictions. Being a father, he knew the dangers of allergies. This is why he follows very strict procedures to ensure that every ingredient is sourced and packed without allergens.
Note: The team at Bake Cravings follows strict hygiene standards to bake sweet cake treats. While their stores are open, they have a one-person-at-a-time policy in their store. Furthermore, shipping and delivery of your cake goes on as usual.
10. Mini Melanie
| BEST FOR | Cake Truffles |
| SELECTION SIZE | Small and medium |
| PRICE RANGE | Starts at $80 |
| DELIVERY FEE | Calculated upon checkout |
| WEBSITE | https://minimelanie.com/ |
| CONTACT | Email: info@minimelanie.com Phone Number: 646.681.4747 |
| PAYMENT | Contact for details |
With so many options out there on the desserts market, you can count on the Moss sisters of Mini Melanie to bring you luxurious desserts such as delicious truffles and cakes to celebrate every life milestone and throughout every gift you send.
11. Stax Ice Cream
| BEST FOR | Ice cream cakes |
| SELECTION SIZE | Small to Large |
| PRICE RANGE | Starts at $19.95 |
| DELIVERY FEE | Calculated upon checkout |
| WEBSITE | https://www.staxicecream.com/ |
| CONTACT | hello@staxicecream.com | (646) 870 – 0214 |
| PAYMENT | Contact for payment options |
Stax Ice Cream is a small shop that’s on a mission to foster a culture of friendship, promote Asian American awareness, all the while enjoying quality ice cream and desserts. All their ice cream flavors are inspired by desserts in their founders’ Asian American culture – subtly sweet but delicious and will satisfy any sweet tooth craving. Their most popular dessert, the Cremella hot-pressed donut ice cream sandwich, allows customers to customize their preferred level of sweetness as they offer plain, vanilla glazed, and chocolate frosted donuts.
Note: Following social distancing measures, Stax Ice Cream’s store is open with curbside pickup.
12. This Chick Bakes
| BEST FOR | Cakes for all occasions |
| SELECTION SIZE | Small to Large |
| PRICE RANGE | Starts at $35.00 |
| DELIVERY FEE | Contact for details |
| WEBSITE | https://www.thischickbakes.com/ |
| CONTACT | Phone: (347)480-8822 Kitchen Phone: (718)706-6616 thischickbakes@gmail.com |
| PAYMENT | Contact for payment options |
This Chick Bakes’s products are made from the finest ingredients they can find. There are no Trans-fats, High fructose corn syrup (HFCS), artificial flavors or preservatives in any of their wedding, event, and other custom cakes. They use fresh ground peanut butter, Callebaut & Chocoa chocolates, organic teas, and pure extracts.
Note: This Chick Bakes is two days away from re-opening its bakery.
13. The Evercake
| BEST FOR | Buttercream cakes |
| SELECTION SIZE | Small to Large |
| PRICE RANGE | $85.00 |
| DELIVERY FEE | Calculated upon checkout |
| WEBSITE | https://theevercake.com/ |
| CONTACT | 201-589-1164 | info@theevercake.com |
| PAYMENT | Amazon, Amex, Apple Pay, Discover, Google Pay, Mastercard, Visa, Shop Pay |
The Evercake delivers simply elegant cakes within the Manhattan area from 125th Street to FiDi. Place your order online anytime and specify the date you need it delivered at checkout. Their courier car service will deliver your cake in perfect condition, ready for you to enjoy.
14. Buttercup Bake Shop
| BEST FOR | Buttercream Cupcakes |
| SELECTION SIZE | Small to Large |
| PRICE RANGE | Starts at $3.25 |
| DELIVERY FEE | Calculated upon checkout |
| WEBSITE | https://www.buttercupbakeshop.com/ |
| CONTACT | Contact form |
| PAYMENT | Contact for payment options |
Using only real ingredients, Buttercup’s classic American desserts are beloved by New Yorkers of all kinds, including Martha Stewart, Al Roker, and Senator Hillary Clinton, among others. A staple in the food culture, Buttercup has also appeared on The Today Show several times, and featured on MTV, Fox, CNN and more, as well as in the romantic novel A Match Made on Madison by Dee Davis.
15. Veneiro’s Pastry
| BEST FOR | New York and strawberry cheesecakes |
| SELECTION SIZE | Small and medium |
| PRICE RANGE | Starts at $18.50 |
| DELIVERY FEE | Calculated upon checkout |
| WEBSITE | http://venierospastry.com/ |
| CONTACT | 212-674-7070 |
| PAYMENT | Visa, MasterCard, American Express, Discover |
Veneiro’s Pastry is a bake shop that specializes in Italian cakes. It was established by Antonio Veneiro in 1894, originally serving only biscotti. Eventually, they expanded to other delicious treats. They are famous for their cannoli, New York cheesecakes and strawberry cheesecakes.
16. Buttermilk Bakeshop
| BEST FOR | Baked treats for your next event |
| SELECTION SIZE | Small, medium, and large |
| PRICE RANGE | Starts at $18 |
| DELIVERY FEE | Contact for more details |
| WEBSITE | https://www.buttermilkbakeshop.com/ |
| CONTACT | (347) 987-3941 |
| PAYMENT | Contact for more details |
Buttermilk Bakeshop is the go-to of many people for beautiful and tasty desserts. From cakes and cupcakes to cookies and macarons, all their menu items are only made with the finest ingredients. Trust that their team is more than capable of making sweet treats for any celebration!
Note: Despite the unprecedented COVID situation, Buttermilk Bakeshop has been trying its best to still serve its customers. They offer contact-free pickup with a limited range of offerings. You can order through UberEats, Seamless, DoorDash, Caviar, Postmates, and Grubhub apps.